Nearly three dozen businesses outside of New York City made the “Top 100 Bagel Shops in New York 2024” ranking by Yelp.
To come up with its list, the restaurant review site identified businesses in the bagel category, then ranked those spots using a number of factors, including the total volume and ratings of reviews.
Yelp’s ranking includes a mix of decades-old storefronts and newcomers making names for themselves post-COVID-19 pandemic.
Menus boast everything from the classics (plain, sesame) to the zany (stuffed with bulgogi and kimchi).
The following businesses, located outside of New York City, made the ranking:
No. 13 – Bagels Santa Fe in East Meadow (Nassau County)
No. 19 – The Bagel Shop & Deli in Middletown (Orange County)
No. 24 – Tomi’s Bites in Hopewell Junction (Dutchess County)
No. 27 – Bagel Train in Suffern (Rockland County)
No. 30 – The Bagel Emporium in Tarrytown (Westchester County)
No. 31 – Downtown Bagels in Middletown (Orange County)
No. 32 – Railroad Bagel Express in Babylon (Suffolk County)
No. 41 – Scarsdale Bagels in Scarsdale (Westchester County)
No. 43 – Country Hot Bagels in Northport (Suffolk County)
No. 44 – Uncommon Grounds Coffee & Tea in Saratoga Springs (Saratoga County)
No. 47 – Broad Street Bagel in Kinderhook (Columbia County)
No. 48 – Nyack Hot Bagels in Nyack (Rockland County)
No. 55 – Pearl’s Bagels & Bakery in Albany
No. 56 The Bagel Emporium in Yorktown Heights (Westchester County)
No. 60 – Wally’s Bagels in North Babylon (Suffolk County)
No. 61 – Park Place Bagels in Bronxville (Westchester County)
No. 63 – Monticello Bagel in Monticello (Sullivan County)
No. 64 – Eastdale Ave Bagels in Poughkeepsie (Dutchess County)
No. 68 – Turnpike Bagels Deli & Bakery in Levittown (Nassau County)
No. 70 – Rhinebeck Bagels & Coffee in Rhinebeck (Dutchess County)
No. 75 – Bagels & Bakes in Schenectady
No. 80 – Lox of Bagels in Saugerties (Ulster County)
No. 81 – Goldberg’s Famous Bagels & Deli in Yonkers (Westchester County)
No. 82 – Zimi Bagel Cafe in Pearl River (Rockland County)
No. 83 – Harrison Bagels in Harrison (Westchester County)
No. 85 – Bagel Plaza in Merrick (Nassau County)
No. 91 – A&S Bagels in Franklin Square (Nassau County)
No. 96 – My Three Sons Bagel Cafe in Stewart Manor (Nassau County)
No. 97 – Village Bagel in Syosset (Nassau County)
No. 100 – Pantano’s Doz Bagels in Garden City Park (Nassau County)
Click here to view Yelp’s complete ranking of the “Top 100 Bagel Shops in New York 2024.”
Click here to follow Daily Voice Shelter Island and receive free news updates.